SHONEN JUMP - The First Volume of the Big Three... How do they hold up?

 


Naruto, by Masashi Kishimoto.

Bleach, by Tite Kubo.  

And last but not least, One Piece, by Eichiro Oda.

The Big Three, as they're called -- juggernauts in not just Japanese media, but pop culture on the whole. All three of them have made their mark on history in the world of modern entertainment. While Ichigo and Luffy may be marginally more obscure, I'd be willing to bet that there's not many children in the western world that don't know who Naruto is.

In my venture at the beginning of this year to consume as much manga as possible, I came upon an idea; what if I gave the big three a try? Despite my large collection and long history with this medium, I honestly had not read or watched hardly any of Naruto, Bleach, or One Piece. I'm not exactly sure why. I was introduced to anime and manga by way of Soul Eater, and then got around to Fullmetal Alchemist, Death Note, Angel Beats, and various other anime that were popular in 2010 - 2012. However, the big three were not on that list. I didn't actively avoid them, but I think their length might have been a bit intimidating. They, along with Dragon Ball and Dragon Ball Z, just never ended up on my radar. 

And I have to admit, they still aren't. I don't intend to read past volume one. This is a writing experiment to see just what I can pull out of a single volume of each series, and I recognize that I won't have necessary context to adequately analyze each of these story's wider narratives. In as such, I'll be looking at what makes up each of their first installments; the art, the panel flow, the action, the characters, the setup, the power systems, and their general beginnings. What I like, and what I don't. I won't be covering each event of the volume unless it's relevant to what I might have to say, so don't expect a full description of whatever happens in the story.

So, let's get started!

---------

One Piece

One Piece is the first volume I read for this essay. It's the longest running and most successful of the three, so why not, right?

I have to admit, I actually have read the first volume of One Piece before, and that's why my copy is slightly older (you can tell with the Shonen Jump logos). I read it my senior year of high school, and it really didn't do much for me at the time. However I have to admit, after a reread and some reflection, I think One Piece isn't half bad. In fact, it's pretty good. 

Within the very first page, we're given a premise and a conflict that are not only easy to grasp, but quickly justifies a broad reason for any of the characters to be going on a journey. A very clear "call to adventure." 

We then jump into Monkey D. Luffy's backstory, which is appropriately simple for the story's beginning. A lot of shonen protagonists are like Luffy. In fact, you can say he's the grand archetype. Shonen obviously predates One Piece, but many stories like Naruto, Black Clover, Fairy Tail, etc. have taken inspiration from Luffy's mannerisms and motivations. He's an actions guy, isn't too bright, but will heroically fight for what he wants and the sake of others.

And Luffy, having eaten the Gum Gum Fruit and now being able to stretch like rubber, is not the only character that stretches and contorts into insane expressions. It's a hallmark of One Piece's cartoonish artstyle, and I have to say that it is quite more caricatured than other manga in its demographic. Everyone is very expressive, sometimes ridiculously so, but it's befitting of the story and the magazine its printed in.

However, this style is the standout. The fluidity in this first volume isn't bad by any means, but it isn't amazing. I've seen some manga really struggle with panel flow and others excel at it, and One Piece falls right in the middle at being quite average with its action and motion. (That's not to say anything against Eichiro Oda's art now, or even his art back then. But everything has shortcomings). 

One Piece's first volume was also very wordy. I don't think this is a downside by any means, but it took longer to read than Bleach and Naruto, and part of that is the sheer volume of character writing shoved into each and every chapter. All very simple stuff, not quite layered or complex, but it is fleshed out. Luffy hoping to one day return Shanks's hat, Koby wanting to be part of the navy, Zolo Zoro's backstory with the character Kuina -- all of it leads me to believe that hopping on the ship with Luffy's crew and reading the rest of the manga will result in some damn good character writing, full of drama and catharsis. Each chapter was an adventure after another, Luffy moving from place to place and amassing a crew at a breakneck speed, making friends, making enemies, and moving on to the next thing. The "call to adventure" here is the best, I think, you might be able to find. 

Sadly, I do have to be honest -- I'm not the biggest fan of One Piece's visual style. I think it works perfectly for the story, but it doesn't quite appeal to me. That's not to say I disliked reading One Piece, nor would I not continue. But the zaniness is a little over the top for me, and while some manga, anime, or cartoons I enjoy quite a lot are even more exaggerated, I just don't think this story's specific blend of it enchanted my reading experience. I recognize that this a nebulous and flawed thing to say, but in reading it I would watch a character's face stretch into a widemouth frown or crumple into a bruised pillow after being punched, and come away thinking, "Yeah, that's certainly One Piece." I wouldn't exactly come away liking that, though.

Luffy's backstory is serviceable, but not groudbreaking. He gets what he needs to get for the story to make sense (return his hat to Shanks and become the King of the Pirates by finding Gold Roger's treasure) but I'm willing to bet that his is the least tragic, unique, or defined backstory in the whole series. Which is, ironically, very befitting of protagonists. 

We didn't get a lot of information of One Piece's magic or power system, but we did get a pretty concrete statement; The Devil Fruit are numerous treasures hidden throughout the world, and grant the eater a specific, unique magical ability at the cost of being able to swim. As a writer, I literally got goosebumps typing that out. It is perfect. It's so, so simple -- but it's easy to understand and allows for a very broad range of action, magics and powers with a boots-hard-on-the-ground drawback, one pirates absolutely should not suffer from. Which, of course, is what makes it so genius. Piracy, sailing, all of that gets ten times more dangerous if you've consumed a devil fruit.

SCORE: 

Protagonist: 6/10

Art: 7/10

Action: 7/10

Power System: 8/10

Story: 7/10

Overall: 7/10

One Piece's first volume holds up. It doesn't specifically have any substantial drawbacks, but it does have things I really like, and things I kinda don't. I have nothing but respect and admiration for Oda's stamina and dedication to his manga, and I have a bit of curiosity in what might happen. But it is nearly 100 volumes long, with no end in sight. Will I continue reading it? Maybe.

-----------

NARUTO

My good graces have officially ended. 

As soon as I opened the book, and saw Naruto defacing "ninja Mount Rushmore," I knew that I'd be in for the long haul. 

I think this is a terrible way to begin the story, honestly. Let's examine what it is; Naruto is defacing an important monument (and we can tell this is a different world because the monument doesn't exist, but resembles a real one and is specifically about something that is integral in this setting), and it doesn't take a genius to realize why that'd be. He's disillusioned with his ninja training and is a loud mouthed little brat, so he's pulling a Charlie in The Santa Clause 2 and is vandalizing something like a hooligan. Now; none of these ideas are bad on their own. In fact, you can quite quickly understand some subtext in the story when the scene all comes together. However, Kishimoto's art isn't good enough to make this convincing. The "ninja Mount Rushmore" looks dumb, Naruto's actions are just ridiculous, so instead it all just comes off as stupid.

Once we get more into the action, which comes in mostly at the second half of the volume, we start to see what the story is made for. The art here works a little better, but it's wildly inconsistent and the scratchy linework is not a fun look. I generally disliked every action scene I read in Naruto, and I can't say the character designs made up for it. Quite the opposite; I found them over designed and woefully boring. Even something like this fox spirit, which I suppose lives inside Naruto, doesn't look that great; 

(And I used this example because it was the best looking page in the volume). 

I recognize that Naruto is a different story from One Piece, but reading it right off the coattails of such a work might not have been the best choice. The entire time, all I could think was, "Yeah, this ain't lookin' too good." The setup of the story is rudimentary with hardly any of the "adventure potential" latent in aforementioned One Piece. Luffy's expressive design and motivations made his shonen-esque outbursts tolerable, and Ichigo is a different kind of character -- more on that later -- but Naruto was outright annoying and frustrating to read about. He's a little shit, through and through, and I can't fault Kishimoto for making him so because he did it effectively. However, where this falls apart, is that nothing Naruto does is funny. It's framed to be funny, but it isn't. 

 
The humor isn't all that suffers; Naruto's first volume has no introduction of a solid antagonist. In One Piece, we're given the impression that wherever Luffy and his crew goes, they will make friends and enemies. Later, in Bleach, the enemies are clearly defined. Obviously having gray morality is 100% alright, as is having no antagonists, in fact, but the lack of a meaningful one in Naruto's opening chapters is noticeable because it's an action story. Their powers, what I can only call "ninjutsu," is not clearly defined to have any boundaries or drawbacks, and that makes action tensionless and leaves much to be desired. This is likely something that's filled in through later reading, but when it's done right at the beginning in One Piece I have no choice but to make the comparison. They ran in the same magazine, so as a kid reading it I'd have to think, "which one would I rather read?" and the answer is obvious. 

SCORE: 

Protagonist: 3/10

Art: 5/10

Action: 5/10

Power System: 4/10

Story: 5/10

Overall: 4/10

Naruto was a snoozefest. I disliked the art, I disliked the action, I disliked the main character, and everything else was as average as it gets. Will I be continuing it? Absolutely not.

-----------

BLEACH

Here we are. Last of the three. How does it hold up? 

Right off the bat, Bleach has a story hook that interested me more than Naruto and One Piece. Ichigo's ability to see ghosts appeals to me on a personal level, because ghosts and the supernatural are themes I really like in stories. Unlike Naruto and One Piece, which have their own worlds, Bleach takes place in ours, which really grounds its conflict. However, the beginning of this story is very barebones and rushed, barreling through ideas with inconsistent dialogue and an underwhelming setup. In my notes, I described Naruto's as boring, but said Bleach's had "actual problems," which I think still rings true. There's so much dialogue in the first few pages that it basically falls into each illustration, which isn't a good thing, and it makes the introduction of the story cluttered. 

Ichigo, though, I liked more than Naruto and Luffy. He has a swagger the others just don't, a unique design and a no nonsense look that stitch together his attitude and actions really fluently. I like him. He might be a bit of a punk, but he's not a runt like Naruto, and he's not over the top like Luffy. He struck a balance that the other two just couldn't, and to me that gives Bleach a lot of promise. 

I don't think the action is paneled well at all, though. When Ichigo is fighting, sword slashes, parries, blocking, and the specific motion of the enemy monsters is, quite literally, all over the place. It was hard to follow any of it, and I won't lie, sometimes it was frustrating to read. Fortunately scenes like this were few and far between, and didn't hamper too much of my reading experience.

After the halfway mark of the first volume, albeit still with its sub-par action flow, Bleach actually got pretty good. The setup of the power system... leaves a bit to be desired (I still don't quite know how it works? Dark energy Soul Reapers have allow them not to be seen by others and give them combat powers that let them reap souls???), and the art is stylistic but not special. However, the few chapters with the character of Orihime and her late brother (who, in the story, became a "hollow," one of the antagonist creatures described as a hungry vengeful spirit) were actually effective emotional story writing. And I have to say, even with the art's faults, the designs of the hollows were really cool. I managed to find a page that showcases all of these things, luckily enough; 

 

SCORE: 

Protagonist: 7/10

Art: 5/10

Action: 5/10

Power System: 6/10

Story: 6/10

Overall: 6/10

For whatever reason, Bleach was the manga I wrote the least about in my notes. I think I know why; it has a few faults, and a few strengths, but none of them are overwhelming to the point where I either hated or loved it. It was just a mildly above average shonen manga, and I unfortunately know a bit too much about the story to warrant reading more. Will I continue it? Probably not.

-------------------

CONCLUSION:

I don't harbor any nostalgic memories with these stories. For a time, after I had finished their first volumes I thought, "what made them so popular?" Why were they so special to so many people?

I don't know if I have the answer to that. It's probably a combination of this; they're simple action adventures with fun story hooks, they have the cartoonish look that children like but the violence and edge of things for older demographics. They are also flagship Shonen Jump titles that made it overseas to a very large audience. Fox's 4kids, Disney XD, Adult Swim's Toonami, all of these networks had their viewers and they provided anime that were quickly becoming popular outside of Japan. Soon, they would conquer the world of not just shonen, not just anime, but animation altogether. And with America's rising manga industry, where they frequently outsell American comics, the source material of course followed this trend.

I sort of regret never having memories of these shows. I wish I had nostalgia for Naruto, looked at Bleach with rose tinted glasses, or wished for adventure while watching Luffy on Fox. While I didn't have these experiences, I'm glad I decided to do this because now I think I have a grasp on each of these franchises better than I did before, at least to some degree. I liked One Piece the most, it's fair to say. However if I didn't know any better I think I'd say that about Bleach. Naruto I didn't like on hardly any level, but that's just about taste. 

In short here is how I'd score the first volumes of each respective series.: One Piece - 7/10 --- Naruto - 4/10 --- Bleach - 6/10. Given a choice? I would continue ONE PIECE!

If you read this far, thank you! I hope I entertained or informed you in some way. Peace!

Comments

Popular Posts